worenweichutaizheiyangdezhengceshiweiletixingdajia,buyaobafabiaolunwenbianchengzhibiaojingsai,anzhaoshuliangpaixudafen。zaijinxingxueshupingjiashi,haiyaozhuzhongwenzhangneirong、yingxianglideng。

亚博APPlunwenbujianglidehua,keyijianglunwenjianglideqiandabaodaopinqirenwuzhong,buzaianzhaozhichengjibiezhidingpinqirenwu,ershibutongderenzhidingbutongdepinqirenwu。jijibengongzi,wanchengpinqirenwudehuakeyiewaijiqian,neijiukeyijianglunwenyujianglituogou,zheiyangyebuhuiyingxianggongzuodejijixing。

亚博APPworenweigaoxiaokeyishedingyigejianglishangxianbiaozhunyuzhi,dongtaidiaozheng。gaoxiaoyingyindizhiyi,tiaojianchengshudeqingkuangxiakeyifenjishixiannianxinzhi,keyiyidingchengducujinkeyantuanduironghe,jianshaokeyangetihu。

亚博APPerduineixiepianyuandiqude、cengcijiaodidegaoxiaolaishuo,quefaxueshulunwen,huozheshuoquefayouzhiqikan、gaoshuipingdelunwen,jinxingjianglishiyizhongtishengxueshushuiping、tishengpaimingdecuoshi。dengdaolunwenzhiliang、shuliangtigaolezhihou,wufazhifugaoedejianglifeiyongle,jiangjinshuipingziranjiuhuijiangdi。

层次较低的高校取消了奖励,还会有人去吗?

duici,youkeyanrenyuanzhichu:“bufengaoxiaomingwenguidingjianglibiaozhun;yeyouxiegaoxiaodejianglihangaizaigangweijintiezhong,gangweijibiebutong,xinchoubutong,yaoqiudelunwenshuliang、qikanyebutong,dabudaoduiyingdejibieyaoqiu,jiuzidongjiangji;haiyouxiejianglunwenhuansuancheng‘jidian’,biruyipianjcr 1qulunwenduiying600dian,1dianyuedengyu50yuan,ji3wanyuan。”

qizhongmingque,“quxiaozhijieyijuscilunwenxiangguanzhibiaoduigerenheyuanxidejiangli”,bingyaoqiu“shuangyiliu”jianshegaoxiaozai7yue31riqianjianchaxiugaixiangguanzhiduwenjianjijianshefangan。

亚博APPliru,《zhongguokexuebao》zhuyidao,youdanweimingqueguiding,fabiaoyipiancnslunwen,jiangjingaoda50wanyuan,youdejigoushenzhijiangli100wanyuan。

“gaoxiaokenenghuizaimingyishangjinxingzonghekaohe,qishifuyulunwendebizhongrengranjiaoda,dacabianqiu”

kendinghuiyingxiangshouru,erqieyingxiangfeichangda。gaoxiaojiaoshidegongzishourupubianjiaodi,wodekeyanjianglizaixuexiaolisuanzhongdengshuiping,keyanjianglizhanshourudebizhongjiaoda。shenzhiyoubufentongshidekeyanjianglikeyidadaobaiwanyuan,tamenshouyingxiangyehenda。

▲ 马军(兰州理工大学理学院教授)

是否有利于改善论文注水、造假现象,鼓励大家追求高水平研究?

▲ 喻海良(中南大学机电工程学院教授)

亚博APPzheiziranyehuiyingxiangjijixing。duiwomenzheixieqingnianjiaoshieryan,jiehunshengzi、maifangdengshenghuoyalihenda。shengcunwentijiejuebule,hetanfazhanni?

mougaoxiaojianglibiaozhun

yixiawei5weigaoxiaojiaoshoudexinsheng。

亚博APPgaoxiaozaizhixingdeshihoubuneng“yidaoqie”,pianmiandebaduikeyanchengguojianglilijieweilunwenjiangli。lunwenzuoweikeyanchengguodezhanxianfangshi,tixianlelaodong,yeshiyanjiushengjiaoxuegongzuodeyanshenhechengguo,wanquanquxiaolunwenjianglibingbushihe。

▲ 李立:

 一篇Nature/Science奖百万成为历史! 5高校教师谈论文与奖励“脱钩”

7yue29ri,kejibu、guojiazirankexuejijinweiyuanhuifabu《guanyujinyibuyashiguojiakejijihua(zhuanxiang、jijindeng)renwuchengdandanweikeyanzuofengxuefenghekeyanchengxinzhutizerendetongzhi》(yixiajiancheng“tongzhi”)。

▲ 蔡宁:

▲ 蔡宁(北京邮电大学人工智能学院副教授)

亚博APPdanduilunwenzaojiazuoyongbuda,henshaoyourenweilejiangjinqufazhushuilunwen。

曾经的高额论文奖励:每篇Nature/Science 100万

▲ 喻海良:

▲ 蔡宁:

guojiazhengcechutaizhihou,xuexiaoziranyeyouxiangyingchutaiyingduizhengce,meiyounagexuexiaozhipinglunwenjinxingjiangli,xuanchengdeshi“zonghekaohe”,danlunwenqueshishisuoyoukaohezhibiaozhongquanzhongzuidadeyixiang。

xuexiaoyaobipaiming、biyoushixueke,duilunwenyoupoqiedexuqiu,jiubazhibiaofenpeidaolemeigelaoshihexueshengtoushang,erqiemeinianhaihuizengjia。gongzishouru、zhaoshengrenshu、shiyanshimianji、bangongshimianjidengdeng,suoyounengxiangdaodeziyuan,douhejixiaoguagou。

亚博APP“jibenshangsuoyoudegaoxiaodoushizheiyang,minglianlidouhuiduilunwenjinxingjiangli。”gaikeyanrenyuangaosu《zhongguokexuebao》。

亚博APPdanruguozheixiegaoxiaoquxiaolejiangli,sheihaihuiquni?

亚博APPguoqu,daduoshukeyanjigouhegaoxiaodouhuiduifabiaoscilunwenjinxingjiangli。ruguofabiaozaidingjiqikanshang,jianglihuigengduo。

▲ 马军:

tongzhizhichu,“bujianglunwenfabiaoshuliang、yingxiangyinziyujianglijiangjinguagou,bushiyongguojiakejijihua(zhuanxiang、jijindeng)zhuanxiangzijinjianglilunwenfabiao。”

……

“gaoxiaojiaoshidejibengongzihendi,lunwenjianglizhanshourudedabufen。yidanquxiao,shengcunwentidoujiejuebule”;

亚博APPcengjingfayipiancns(zhi3gedingjiqikancell 、naturehescience)lunwenjiangligaoda100wanyuan,rujinzhongyuchengweilishi!

亚博APPqishi,zaozaijinnian2yue,yaboguanfangshoujiban、kejibujiufabule《guanyuguifangaodengxuexiaoscilunwenxiangguanzhibiaoshiyongshulizhengquepingjiadaoxiangderuoganyijian》。

▲ 李立(化名,东部地区某高校副教授):

7yue29ri,kejibu、jijinweifabuzhongbangtongzhi,mingque“bujianglunwenfabiaoshuliang、yingxiangyinziyujianglijiangjinguagou。”

▲ 张风(化名,东部某高校教授)

jianglijiangderangrenxintiao,chengfafaderangrenhuobuxiaqu。

亚博APPwoshinianxinzhide,duiwodeshourumeiyouyingxiang。

lunwenjiangliliyongdeshi“manyuxiaoying”。xuexiaocailiyouxian,nengnadaogaoejiangliderenshihenshaoshu,dankeyijinxingzhaopinxuanchuan、xiyinrencai。

 一篇Nature/Science奖百万成为历史! 5高校教师谈论文与奖励“脱钩”

xuexiaozhijiandechayihenda。duiyuwomenzheizhong“shuangfei”gaoxiaolaishuo,xiangyaozuochugaoshuipingyanjiushifeichangkunnande,yebunengnaduiqingbeideyaoqiulaiyaoqiusuoyougaoxiao。kuangqie,liangbiancainengyinqizhibian,meiyouzugoudeshuliangjilei,yehennanyixiaziyougaoshuipingdeyanjiu。

ciqian,yaboguanfangshoujibanyecengfawenqiangdiao,“quxiaozhijieyijuscilunwendejiangli”。

liangcizhongbangtongzhi,chedijianglunwenyujiangli“tuogou”。zheihuijianshaokeyanrenyuandeshouruma?meiyoulelunwenhejiangliqudong,tamenzuokeyandejijixingshifouhuishoudaomingxianyingxiang?lunwen“zhushui”、zaojiawentijiangzaiduodachengdushangdeyigaishan?weilaidekaohetixihequhecong?

woxianzaihenjiujie,yehenmimang。ruguolunwenjiangliquanbuquxiao,meiyoujingjibaozhang,zuoxueshuduiwolaishuojiushishewang。

gaoxiaodejianglibuzhilunwen,haiyoushenqingdeketixiangmu、huodegezhongjiangxiang、zhuanlizhuanrangyufabiaodengdeng。zheilimianzuirongyizuodejiushifabiaolunwen,suoyidajiadouquzuojiandandeshierle。guojiaxiangjiupian,chuzhongshihaode。

亚博APPzhengcedechufadianshihaode,guanjianshizenmezhixing。

▲ 喻海良: